Back
View All
  1. Home
  2. Numismatic Coins
  3. Rare U.S. Coins
  4. All Rare U.S. Coins
Mitch Hyatt

Can't find what you want?

We are here to help. Contact us.

All Rare U.S. Coins

127 Products
Clear filters
  Show Filters
In stock
1793 Lettered Edge (2)
1793 Large Cents Flowing Hair 1793 PCGS Genuine - Fine Details (97 - Environmental Damage) BN Wreath, Lettered Edge
Add to Cart
In stock
1794 S-65 BN (2)
1794 Large Cents Liberty Cap NGC VF Details BN S-65
Add to Cart
In stock
1839 BN (2)
1839 Braided Hair Cent NGC VF-30 BN Silly Head - Lamination Error
Add to Cart
In stock
1853 BN (2)
1853 Braided Hair Cent NGC XF-40 BN
Add to Cart
In stock
1856 BN (2)
1856 Braided Hair Cent NGC AU-50 BN Upright 5
Add to Cart
In stock
1857 Small Cents Flying Eagle PCGS AU-55 Flying Eagle
1857 Small Cents Flying Eagle PCGS AU-55 Flying Eagle
Add to Cart
In stock
1857 Small Cents Flying Eagle PCGS MS-63 Flying Eagle Obv. Clash w/ 50C, FS-402, S-9
1857 Small Cents Flying Eagle PCGS MS-63 Flying Eagle Obv. Clash w/ 50C, FS-402, S-9
Add to Cart
In stock
1857 CLASHED WITH 50C OBVERSE (2)
1857 Small Cents Flying Eagle NGC VG Details CLASHED WITH 50C OBVERSE
Add to Cart
In stock
1858 SMALL (2)
1858 Small Cents Flying Eagle NGC F-15 SMALL
Add to Cart
In stock
1858 LARGE (2)
1858 Small Cents Flying Eagle NGC VF-20 LARGE
Add to Cart
In stock
1858 LARGE (2)
1858 Small Cents Flying Eagle NGC VF-20 LARGE
Add to Cart
In stock
1858 SMALL (2)
1858 Small Cents Flying Eagle NGC VF-25 SMALL
Add to Cart
In stock
1858 SMALL (2)
1858 Small Cents Flying Eagle NGC VF-35 SMALL
Add to Cart
In stock
1858 Small Cents Flying Eagle PCGS VF-35 Large Letters
1858 Small Cents Flying Eagle PCGS VF-35 Large Letters
Add to Cart
In stock
1858 Small Cents Flying Eagle PCGS XF-40 Large Letters
1858 Small Cents Flying Eagle PCGS XF-40 Large Letters
Add to Cart
In stock
1868 BN (2)
1868 Small Cents Indian Head NGC XF-40 BN
Add to Cart
In stock
1870 Small Cents Indian Head PCGS F-15 BN
1870 Small Cents Indian Head PCGS F-15 BN
Add to Cart
In stock
1872 Small Cents Indian Head PCGS F-12 BN
1872 Small Cents Indian Head PCGS F-12 BN
Add to Cart
In stock
1872 Small Cents Indian Head PCGS VF-25 BN
1872 Small Cents Indian Head PCGS VF-25 BN
Add to Cart
In stock
1872 Small Cents Indian Head PCGS VF-30 BN
1872 Small Cents Indian Head PCGS VF-30 BN
Add to Cart
In stock
1872 BN (2)
1872 Small Cents Indian Head NGC XF-40 BN
Add to Cart
In stock
1873 BN (2)
1873 Small Cents Indian Head NGC XF-45 BN Open 3
Add to Cart
In stock
1876 Small Cents Indian Head PCGS VF-30 BN
1876 Small Cents Indian Head PCGS VF-30 BN
Add to Cart
In stock
1877 BN (2)
1877 Small Cents Indian Head NGC AG-3 BN
Add to Cart
In stock
1909 VDB 1C, RD
1909 Small Cents Lincoln, Wheat Ears Reverse PCGS MS-65 RD VDB
Add to Cart
In stock
1909 VDB 1C, RD
1909 Small Cents Lincoln, Wheat Ears Reverse PCGS MS-65 RD VDB
Add to Cart
In stock
1909 VDB 1C, RD
1909 Small Cents Lincoln, Wheat Ears Reverse PCGS MS-65+ RD VDB
Add to Cart
In stock
1909-S VDB 1C, BN (2)
1909-S Small Cents Lincoln, Wheat Ears Reverse PCGS AU-58+ BN VDB
Add to Cart
In stock
1909-S VDB 1C, BN (2)
1909-S Small Cents Lincoln, Wheat Ears Reverse PCGS Genuine - XF Details (95 - Scratch) BN VDB
Add to Cart
In stock
Small Cents-Lincoln, Wheat Ears Reverse
1914-D Small Cents Lincoln, Wheat Ears Reverse ANACS G-6
Add to Cart
In stock
1936 RD (2)
1936 Small Cents Lincoln, Wheat Ears Reverse NGC MS-66 RD
Add to Cart
In stock
1936 1C Satin, RB (2)
1936 Small Cents Lincoln, Wheat Ears Reverse PCGS PR-64 RB Satin
Add to Cart
In stock
1955 1C Doubled Die Obverse, BN (2)
1955 Small Cents Lincoln, Wheat Ears Reverse PCGS AU-55 BN Doubled Die Obverse
Add to Cart
In stock
Small Cents-Lincoln, Memorial Reverse 1959-2006 -Copper
1983 Small Cents Lincoln, Memorial Reverse ANACS MS-64 Error - Unplated
Add to Cart
In stock
Small Cents-Lincoln, Memorial Reverse 1959-2006 -Copper
1985 Small Cents Lincoln, Memorial Reverse ANACS MS-64 Error - Unplated
Add to Cart
In stock
Small Cents-Lincoln, Memorial Reverse 1959-2006 -Copper
1999 Small Cents Lincoln, Memorial Reverse ANACS MS-65 Red Error - Off-Center
Add to Cart
In stock
1999 OFF CENTER RD
1999 Small Cents Lincoln, Memorial Reverse NGC MS-65 RD OFF CENTER
Add to Cart
In stock
Small Cents-Lincoln, Memorial Reverse 1959-2006 -Copper
2000 Small Cents Lincoln, Memorial Reverse ANACS MS-67 Cheerios
Add to Cart
In stock
2003-D Small Cents Lincoln, Memorial Reverse NGC MS-67 RD
2003-D Small Cents Lincoln, Memorial Reverse NGC MS-67 RD
Add to Cart
In stock
2007-D Small Cents Lincoln, Memorial Reverse NGC MS-66 RD
2007-D Small Cents Lincoln, Memorial Reverse NGC MS-66 RD
Add to Cart
In stock
1880 3CN
1880 Nickel Three Cent Pieces PCGS PR-64
Add to Cart
In stock
1936 5C Satin (2)
1936 Nickel Indian Head or Buffalo PCGS PR-66 Satin
Add to Cart
In stock
1984 OBVERSE BROCKAGE 6FS (2)
1984 Nickel Jefferson NGC MS-62 6FS OBVERSE BROCKAGE
Add to Cart
In stock
2002 ULTRA CAMEO
2002-S Nickel Jefferson NGC PF-69 ULTRA CAMEO
Add to Cart
In stock
2003 ULTRA CAMEO
2003-S Nickel Jefferson NGC PF-69 ULTRA CAMEO
Add to Cart
In stock
Nickel Five Cent Pieces-Jefferson
ND Nickel Jefferson ANACS MS-60 Error - Stuck on Fragment
Add to Cart
In stock
1916-D 10C (2)
1916-D Dimes Winged Liberty Head or Mercury PCGS FR-2
Add to Cart
In stock
Dimes---Roosevelt 1965-Present-Copper-Nickel- 1 Dime
1969-D Dimes Roosevelt ANACS XF-45 Error - Missing Clad Layer
Add to Cart
Showing 1-48 of 127 Products

Charlotte's Oldest and Largest Coin Shop
Since 1959

Your Cart
Final pricing determined in checkout after payment method is selected
Est. Total:
Secure Checkout
Continue to Checkout