• 704-394-0387                                                                Charlotte, Nc Since 1959
Back
View All
  1. Home
  2. Shop For Numismatic Coins Locally In Charlotte, NC
  3. Rare U.S. Coins
  4. All Rare U.S. Coins
Mitch Hyatt

Can't find what you want?

We are here to help. Contact us.

All Rare U.S. Coins

454 Products
Clear filters
  Show Filters
In stock
1961 STRUCK ON SPLIT PLANCHET BEFORE STRIKE (1.7g) RB (3)
1961 Small Cents Lincoln, Memorial Reverse NGC UNC Details RB STRUCK ON SPLIT PLANCHET BEFORE STRIKE (1.7g)
Add to Cart
In stock
Small Cents-Lincoln, Memorial Reverse 1959-2006 -Copper
1983 Small Cents Lincoln, Memorial Reverse ANACS MS-64 Error - Unplated
Add to Cart
In stock
1983 1C, RD (2)
1983 Small Cents Lincoln, Memorial Reverse PCGS MS-64 RD Off Center Error
Add to Cart
In stock
Small Cents-Lincoln, Memorial Reverse 1959-2006 -Copper
1985 Small Cents Lincoln, Memorial Reverse ANACS MS-64 Error - Unplated
Add to Cart
In stock
Small Cents-Lincoln, Memorial Reverse 1959-2006 -Copper (3)
2000 Small Cents Lincoln, Memorial Reverse ANACS MS-67 Cheerios
Add to Cart
In stock
2019 First Day of Issue First
2019-W Small Cents Lincoln, Shield Reverse NGC MS-69 RD First Day of Issue First "W" Uncirculated Ct
Add to Cart
In stock
2019 First Day of Issue First
2019-W Small Cents Lincoln, Shield Reverse NGC PF-69 RD First Day of Issue First "W" Reverse Pf Cent
Add to Cart
In stock
2019 First Day of Issue First
2019-W Small Cents Lincoln, Shield Reverse NGC PF-69 RD ULTRA CAMEO First Day of Issue First "W" Mint Mark Cent
Add to Cart
In stock
2020 First Day of Issue 10-Coin Clad Proof Set Official US Mint Set RD ULTRA CAMEO (4)
2020-S Small Cents Lincoln, Shield Reverse NGC PF-70 RD ULTRA CAMEO
Add to Cart
In stock
2023 1C Shield, Extra
2022 Small Cents Lincoln, Bicentennial PCGS MS-65 RD Shield Shield, Extra "V"
Add to Cart
In stock
1883 3CN (2)
1883 Nickel Three Cent Pieces PCGS PR-65
Add to Cart
In stock
1886 3CN (2)
1886 Nickel Three Cent Pieces PCGS PR-62
Add to Cart
In stock
1884 5C
1884 Nickel Liberty Head PCGS VF-35
Add to Cart
In stock
1891 5C (2)
1891 Nickel Liberty Head PCGS MS-63
Add to Cart
In stock
1892 5C
1892 Nickel Liberty Head PCGS AU-55
Add to Cart
In stock
1900 5C (4)
1900 Nickel Liberty Head PCGS MS-62
Add to Cart
In stock
1900 5C (3)
1900 Nickel Liberty Head PCGS MS-63
Add to Cart
In stock
1905 5C (2)
1905 Nickel Liberty Head PCGS MS-63
Add to Cart
In stock
1906 5C
1906 Nickel Liberty Head PCGS MS-62
Add to Cart
In stock
1908 5C (4)
1908 Nickel Liberty Head PCGS AU-58
Add to Cart
In stock
1912-S 5C (4)
1912-S Nickel Liberty Head PCGS AU-55
Add to Cart
In stock
1913 5C Type 1 (2)
1913 Nickel Indian Head or Buffalo PCGS MS-65 Type 1
Add to Cart
In stock
1913-S 5C Type 2 (3)
1913-S Nickel Indian Head or Buffalo PCGS AU-58 Type 2
Add to Cart
In stock
1913-S 5C Type 2
1913-S Nickel Indian Head or Buffalo PCGS G-4 Type 2
Add to Cart
In stock
1918/7-D 5C (3)
1918/7-D Nickel Indian Head or Buffalo PCGS G-4 1918/7-D
Add to Cart
In stock
1921 5C (2)
1921 Nickel Indian Head or Buffalo PCGS MS-64 Rainbow Toned
Add to Cart
In stock
1936 5C Satin (2)
1936 Nickel Indian Head or Buffalo PCGS PR-66 Satin
Add to Cart
In stock
1937 D (2)
1937-D Nickel Indian Head or Buffalo NGC VF Details 3 LEGS
Add to Cart
In stock
1937-D 5C 3 Legs
1937-D Nickel Indian Head or Buffalo PCGS VF-35 3 Legs
Add to Cart
In stock
1937-D 5C 3 Legs (2)
1937-D Nickel Indian Head or Buffalo PCGS XF-40 3 Legs
Add to Cart
In stock
1984 OBVERSE BROCKAGE 6FS (2)
1984 Nickel Jefferson NGC MS-62 6FS OBVERSE BROCKAGE
Add to Cart
In stock
Nickel Five Cent Pieces-Jefferson
ND Nickel Jefferson ANACS MS-60 Error - Stuck on Fragment
Add to Cart
In stock
JEFFERSON BN (2)
Unknown Nickel Jefferson NGC MS-64 BN Struck Off Center on 1C Blank
Add to Cart
In stock
1858 (2)
1858-O Liberty Seated Half Dime NGC XF Details
Add to Cart
In stock
1854 10C Arrows S.S. Central America #2 (with Pinch) (2)
1854 Liberty Seated Dime PCGS XF-45 SS Central America Arrows
Add to Cart
In stock
1887-S 10C
1887-S Liberty Seated Dime PCGS AU-55
Add to Cart
In stock
1892-O 10C (2)
1892-O Dimes Barber or Liberty Head PCGS XF-40
Add to Cart
In stock
1916-D 10C (2)
1916-D Dimes Winged Liberty Head or Mercury PCGS Genuine - VG Details (92 - Cleaned)
Add to Cart
In stock
1916-D 10C (4)
1916-D Dimes Winged Liberty Head or Mercury PCGS VF-35
Add to Cart
In stock
1926-S 10C (3)
1926-S Dimes Winged Liberty Head or Mercury PCGS AU-53
Add to Cart
In stock
1928-S 10C (2)
1928-S Dimes Winged Liberty Head or Mercury PCGS MS-62
Add to Cart
In stock
1942
1942 Dimes Winged Liberty Head or Mercury NGC PF-66
Add to Cart
New
1942/1 10C Overdate, FS-101 (2)
1942 Dimes Winged Liberty Head or Mercury PCGS Genuine - VF Details (92 - Cleaned) Overdate FS-101
Add to Cart
In stock
1943 FB
1943-D Dimes Winged Liberty Head or Mercury NGC MS-66 FB
Add to Cart
In stock
1945-D 10C (3)
1945-D Dimes Winged Liberty Head or Mercury PCGS MS-66
Add to Cart
In stock
Dimes---Roosevelt 1965-Present-Copper-Nickel- 1 Dime
1969-D Dimes Roosevelt ANACS XF-45 Error - Missing Clad Layer
Add to Cart
In stock
1875-S 20C
1875-S Seated Liberty Twenty Cents PCGS VF-30
Add to Cart
In stock
1854 (2)
1854 Seated Liberty Quarter PCGS AU-58 Arrows
Add to Cart
Showing 97-144 of 454 Products

Charlotte's Oldest and Largest Coin Shop
Since 1959

Your Cart
Final pricing determined in checkout after payment method is selected
Est. Total:
Secure Checkout
Continue to Checkout